Buyer's Guide

Your Router Is Probably Not Protecting You Enough

Published March 27, 2026 · Last reviewed March 31, 2026 · 6 min read · ismyroutersafe.com Editorial

Premium WiFi mesh router
In this article
  1. How urgent is your situation?
  2. When replacement is critical
  3. What top protection looks like
  4. Routers that meet the bar
  5. Good routers - and why good isn't enough
  6. Special case: ISP gateways
Our honest point of view: Every router we've analyzed has security gaps - some catastrophic, some modest. The right standard isn't "safe enough." It's the highest protection you can reasonably have.

How urgent is your situation?

The question is how fast you need to move. Find your situation below: your timeline is days, months, or "when it makes sense."

Your situationAction
TP-Link router in active useReplace - critical. CISA Volt Typhoon advisory, active federal investigation, documented attack vector.
Any router at end-of-life (no more patches)Replace - critical. An unpatched router is a permanently open door.
Tenda or Huawei routerReplace - critical. Documented backdoors (Tenda) or fully banned from the US market (Huawei).
ISP gateway (Xfinity, AT&T, Verizon, Spectrum)Secure now - upgrade when ready. Harden it now. Add a security-focused router behind it when you can.
Older Netgear in active supportMaintain - plan your upgrade. Still patched, but Netgear's support history is uneven.
Current-generation Asus, Eero, Google Nest, LinksysSolid hardware - consider your ceiling. Good routers, so you're not in crisis, but not the highest protection available.
Router over 5 years old (any brand)Replace promptly. Age alone puts hardware near or past end-of-life.

When replacement is critical

1. End-of-life routers

This is the most important replacement trigger, whatever the brand. After end-of-life, no new vulnerability will ever be fixed, and no setting makes up for that.

Key end-of-life models to replace immediately: TP-Link Archer C7, Netgear Nighthawk R7000, Linksys EA9500, D-Link DIR-842, Apple AirPort Extreme, any Asus RT-N series.

2. TP-Link routers - all models

The CISA advisory (AA23-144A), the active DOJ/FCC investigation, and TP-Link's role in Volt Typhoon apply to every firmware version. Even a fully-updated TP-Link carries risk from Chinese national intelligence law.

If your network touches anything sensitive (work, banking, healthcare, kids' devices), TP-Link is not an acceptable risk.

3. Tenda routers with documented backdoors

Tenda's AC23 has a documented backdoor vulnerability (CVE-2020-10987) rated 9.8/10 that was never properly patched. No patch is coming, so replace it.

What top protection looks like

Most routers are built to connect you. Security routers are built to protect you while connected. Here's the difference:

What a security-first router provides
✓
Always-on network-level VPN - encrypts traffic at the router, so it covers smart home devices that can't run VPN apps
✓
Zero-Trust device isolation - devices can't talk to each other unless you allow it, so a hacked smart TV can't reach your laptop
✓
Clean US jurisdiction, no intelligence law exposure - US-headquartered, Taiwan-made, and outside Chinese or Russian intelligence laws
✓
Current FCC authorization - verifiable in the FCC Equipment Authorization Database, no Covered List designation
✓
Automatic security updates - patches apply without you doing anything
✓
WPA3 encryption - far more resistant to offline password attacks and eavesdropping than WPA2
✓
Dedicated security team with fast CVE response - security is the core product, not an add-on

Routers that meet the bar

All have current FCC authorization, active patch support, and no Chinese ownership. As of March 2026, ordered by protection:

Highest protection - security as the primary design goal

Strong hardware - serious protection, some gaps

Acceptable options - convenient, but privacy trade-offs

Budget options

A note on "US brand" routers: Netgear, Google, and Amazon/Eero are US-headquartered but build mostly in Vietnam and Southeast Asia, so the FCC ban may affect new models. Existing authorized models are fine to buy. We'll update this as the Conditional Approval process develops.

Good routers - and why good isn't enough

If you have a current-generation Asus, Eero, Google Nest, or AT&T/Verizon ISP gateway, you're not in crisis. These are decent products with reasonable security records.

But "no known problems" is a low bar. They patch known flaws, but lack defense-in-depth: isolating hacked devices, encrypting all traffic before it leaves home, and real control over your devices.

Keeping yours? Turn on auto-updates, change all default passwords, and check our database for new disclosures about your model.

Special case: ISP gateways

Your ISP controls the gateway's firmware. You can't install updates yourself, and advanced security settings are often locked.

Immediate steps if you're on an ISP gateway:

  1. Secure your ISP account with a strong unique password and 2-factor authentication. A hacked ISP account can give remote access to your gateway.
  2. Disable public Wi-Fi hotspot broadcasting (Xfinity gateways enable it by default).
  3. Put the gateway in bridge/passthrough mode with a dedicated security router behind it. This is the only way to get real control while keeping your ISP service.
  4. Ask your ISP about upgrades. Many offer newer gateways at no cost on older models.
🔍
Not sure where your router stands? Check your model → for a full report with score and grade.

Disclosure: Rio builds and runs ismyroutersafe.com, and the Rio Router is graded by the same method as every other router. No other manufacturer pays for placement. See the methodology page.